Homemade Nutella

Hi Everyone,

Since the holidays I have had a major sweet tooth, but I’m trying, key word is trying to stay away, but until then I must share with you my latest creation.   He he, I am just so proud of today’s recipe.  It is pretty darn close to the classic hazelnut chocolate spread, Nutella.

If you have been following me for a while, you will know I discovered Nutella this summer when I was in Europe.  I have heard, and seen so many recipes using it, but I never gave it a second thought.  When in Paris, I was making a parfait at the breakfast bar and they didn’t have peanut butter and I saw the Nutella.  I figured I’d give it a try since it was everywhere in Paris.  I dipped my figured into my packet and that was it, it was all over, I was in love!!  Dam!!  When I came home, I noticed Nutella was everywhere here too!!  I bought a jar, then another and another.  This stuff is dangerous!!!  After reading the ingredients, I realized the first ingredient wasn’t hazelnuts, but sugar!  Eck!!!  The second is palm oil, then hazelnuts.   I realized I can do so much better than this!! So I grabbed my half empty jar of Nutella, a bag of hazelnuts and got to work!

I added my hazelnuts to my food processor, processed it until it was a peanut butter consistency, then the tough part began.  What to add to make it more healthy, but give it the sweet taste, plus a nice spreadable consistency   I started with unsweetened cocoa powder, vanilla extract and 3 tablespoons of powdered sugar.  I processed more and realized the consistency was to thick, so I added two tablespoons of coconut oil and processed more.  It was good, but I wanted better.  I added 1 tbsp. of mini chocolate chips to give it more of a milk chocolate flavor since Nutella contains milk.  I didn’t want to add milk, because I just thought that was weird and whats even stranger is you don’t refrigerate Nutella so how does the milk not go bad?  Everything was good, I tested my Nutella to my jar of Nutella and the original Nutella was sweeter, so I added one packet of stevia and bam, there it is!!  A pretty spot on version of Nutella!!  I like mine better because it’s more natural and I feel better having it, not to mention mine is a tad healthier.

The stats on Nutella from the store are 2 tbsp:  Calories:  200,  Fat:  12,  Sodium:  15,  Carbs:  21,  Fiber:  1,  Sugar:  21,  Protein:  2

PB&P’s homemade Nutella:  Calories:  171,  Fat:  14.6,  Sodium:  11.9,  Carbs:  7.2,  Fiber:  3.3,  Sugar:  3.7,   Protein  3.9

Big difference in Carbs, Fiber, Sugar and Protein!  I feel so much better having my version of Nutella!!  I think if you try it you will be pleasantly surprised on how much it tastes like Nutella!  The whole process takes 10 minutes and it’s pretty darn easy too!!

Homemade Nutella
Nutrition Information
  • Serves: 1⅓ cups
  • Serving size: 2 tbsp.
    Prep time: 
    Cook time: 
    Total time: 
    A sweet and creamy hazelnut chocolate spread
    • 2 cups hazelnuts, roasted, peeled
    • 2 tbsp. unsweetened cocoa powder
    • ½ tbsp. vanilla extract
    • 3 tbsp. powdered sugar
    • 1 packet stevia (1/4 tsp) or 1 more tbsp. powdered sugar
    • pinch salt
    • 2 tbsp. coconut oil
    • 1 tbsp. mini chocolate chips
    1. In a food processor, add hazelnuts and process until a peanut butter consistency. Add cocoa powder, vanilla extract, powdered sugar, stevia, salt and coconut oil. Process until smooth. Add chocolate chips and process until melted.
    2. Place in a jar and seal with a top.
    To peel hazelnuts place them in a tea towel and rub them, the skin will come right off. It's ok, if a few skins remain.

    Calories per two tablespoons: 171, Fat: 14.6, Sodium: 11.9, Carbs: 7.2, Fiber: 3.3, Sugar: 3.7, Protein 3.9

    I’m going to be honest with you, I am not going to be buying Nutella anymore.  I am so happy and pleased with my version and I love that it is healthier for you!!  Love the sugar comparison and I think my growing butt will thank me too!!  🙂

    Oh and if you never had Nutella, your missing out!  It’s a creamy, chocolaty, sweet hazelnut butter.  Dam it’s good, but mine’s better 😉

    Have a great day everyone!




    1. I have made my own Nutella spread for a few months now. I don’t have a food processor, so I cheat by buying a 500g jar of plain hazelnut butter. Then I add about 3 tbsp of cocoa & 3 tbsp of coconut sugar. You can add more to taste. I really like the consistancy & find nothing else needs to be added. Please try it for yourself. I found it tastes even better after sitting for a few days to let the flavours really blend!

    2. homemade nutella would be DANGEROUS in our home! i love that you had such great success with it and that you’ll be making it at home from now on… don’t you just love that?!

    3. Oh my! You have really outdone yourself on this one! I LOVE Nutella, I put it on everything!! Well, almost everything 😀 This looks so great!

    4. I will follow you to not buy Nutella anymore. Your nutella recipe will be my recipe now. Thank you..

    5. It would be dangerous to even have this around for me! 🙂

    6. This is so clever. I’ve been seeing a lot of nut butters around but this post really inspires me to make my own Nutella. I love the consistensy of yours too!

    7. I LOVE nutella and would even give it to my kids for breakfast UNTIL I read that it has more sugar than chocolate frosting. I didn’t actually compare the nutella and frosting to see if its true but it did make me scrutinize the nutritional label. So we stopped buying nutella and my kids miss it…so do I! (Guilty of eating this by the spoonful!!!) I look forward to trying your recipe. Thanks!

    8. dianaramblesdotcom says

      This looks yummier than Nutella! Thanks for linking up!!

    9. Amazing! My son LOVES that stuff. He dips apple slices in it. I really need to try your version. Thanks so much for linking up on Super Sweet Saturday.

    10. This is awesome!! I’ve seen a few recipes for homemade Nutella, all a little bit different. I’ll have to do a bake off one of these days…

    11. jen just wanted to let you know we featured you today on friday food frenzy
      http://www.stayingclosetohome.com/2013/01/friday-food-frenzy-ringing-in-new-year.html hope you come link up today too

    12. I am sooooooo trying this! YUMMMM! Did you make this recipe up yourself? How do the nutritionals compare to store bought nutella?

      • Yes, I made the recipe myself. Here are the stat comparisons: The stats on Nutella from the store are 2 tbsp: Calories: 200, Fat: 12, Sodium: 15, Carbs: 21, Fiber: 1, Sugar: 21, Protein: 2

        PB&P’s homemade Nutella: Calories: 171, Fat: 14.6, Sodium: 11.9, Carbs: 7.2, Fiber: 3.3, Sugar: 3.7, Protein 3.9

        Mine has less sugar, plus Nutella is not vegan and it’s filled with a lot of processed stuff that I don’t even know what it is.

    13. can you use a regular blender to make this? And can you use olive oil instead? I don’t want the unhealthy fats…


    1. […] I discovered Nutella was made with stuff I didn’t know and it is far from natural.  Plus you Guys informed me that Nutella isn’t healthy.  I thought I was getting a nice chocolate nut butter but come to find out it’s loaded with sugar!  So what does one do when they now have a Nutella addiction?  Make your own!  So I did, you can find the recipe here. […]

    2. […] made the filling with my homemade Nutella and my newest cheese love, Mascarpone Cheese.  Oh my gosh, I love that darn cheese!  I am not a […]

    Speak Your Mind


    Rate this recipe: